Skip to main content
Insurance ClaimsMotor Vehicle Accident

Questions the Insurance Company Will Ask You After a Louisiana Car Accident

By February 21, 2024May 15th, 2024No Comments

Your auto insurance company is keenly interested in any collision involving one of their insured vehicles. 

What you convey to your insurance provider could significantly impact subsequent legal proceedings, the terms of your coverage, and the compensation you receive to address accident-related expenses.

To safeguard your legal rights and ensure fair compensation, it’s crucial to seek the knowledge and skills of seasoned auto accident attorneys, such as our Baton Rouge-based team at Pierce & Shows.

The Interview with Your Baton Rouge Insurance Company

It is vital to discuss your Baton Rouge accident with your insurance company. In fact, failure to notify your insurer of an auto accident in a timely manner could seriously jeopardize your car insurance policy and benefits. This could potentially lead to coverage termination, representation refusal, or increased premiums.

Typically, your insurance company will initiate contact for a phone interview.  They might request permission to record the conversation. However, if you are uncomfortable being recorded, you may refuse politely.

In exceptional cases, they might request an in-person meeting at their office. Remember, this isn’t an interrogation to put you on the hot seat but a discussion to present the facts of the case. 

Avoid speculation or opinions, and refrain from admitting fault, as details may be unclear, and admissions can be used against you later on.

Common Interview Questions Your Baton Rouge Insurance Company May Ask

In the aftermath of a car accident in Baton Rouge or any area in Louisiana, navigating through the questions from your insurance company can feel overwhelming. 

Here are the commonly asked questions you might encounter and some general thoughts on how to approach them:

  1. Where and when did the accident happen? 

Detailing the precise location and time of the accident is crucial for insurance documentation. Note landmarks, street names, and any relevant timestamps to give your insurance company a clear picture of the incident.

  1. Who was involved in the auto accident? 

Collecting identifying information from all involved parties is essential for insurance claims. Ensure you gather names, addresses, contact numbers, driver’s license details, and insurance information. 

  1. How did the accident happen?

When recounting the events of the accident, focus on providing a factual narrative devoid of personal interpretation or bias. Stick to the sequence of events as you recall them, avoiding speculative statements or assumptions.

  1. Who caused the accident?

While feeling compelled to assign blame is natural during these circumstances, it is of the utmost importance to refrain from admitting fault during these discussions. If you are unsure how to answer, just say, “I don’t know,” or “I defer to the investigation.”

  1. Did the police file a report? 

Involving law enforcement is crucial for documenting the accident and establishing an official record. If the police are not present at the scene, ask them to come to your assistance immediately after the accident so they can file an accident report. This report serves as a vital piece of evidence in insurance claims and legal proceedings, offering an impartial account of the incident.

Every car accident case is different. That’s why it is of the utmost importance to contact an experienced Louisiana accident attorney to work with you as soon as possible after the accident – even to walk you through talking to your insurance company.

Dealing With Louisiana Car Accident Insurance Companies: Dos and Don’ts

Saying the wrong thing during conversations with your car insurance company following an accident could mean accidentally admitting fault. 

Therefore, if you find yourself in a conversation with an insurance company—whether it’s your own insurer or the other driver’s—here are some general tips for methods to navigate the situation:


  • Provide Personal Information: When requested, give them your name, address, and contact number. 
  • Stick to Facts: Stick to what you observed and experienced firsthand, avoiding subjective interpretations.
  • Document Correspondence: Record your communication with the insurance company, including dates, times, and the content of conversations. 
  • Seek Legal Counsel: If unsure about how to proceed or if legal complexities arise, seek guidance from experienced attorneys focusing on car accident cases, such as Pierce & Shows. Legal counsel can provide invaluable insights and advocacy to protect your rights and interests.


  • Admit Fault: Refrain from admitting fault or accepting blame for the accident, even if pressured to do so. Instead, defer fault determination to the investigative process.
  • Discuss Injury Details: Avoid directly providing detailed information about your injuries or medical condition to the insurance company. Defer the question to your doctor or just say you can’t discuss the matter. Seek consultation from your personal injury attorney regarding this matter.
  • Agree to Recorded Statements: Never agree to a recorded statement when your attorney is not present. Recorded statements can be used against you in negotiations or legal proceedings. Politely decline and indicate that you’ll provide a statement with legal counsel present.
  • Accept Immediate Settlement Offers: Do not accept a settlement offer from the insurance company, no matter how good it might seem on the surface. Wait and discuss the matter with your attorney. 
  • Engage in Confrontation: Opt for diplomacy and assertiveness when advocating for your rights and interests, considering your consultation with your car accident lawyer.

Protect Your Interests with Pierce & Shows: Trusted Louisiana Car Accident Attorneys

Don’t face insurer inquiries unprepared, potentially risking your rights and compensation. Our Baton Rouge-based team at Pierce & Shows stands ready to assist you, ensuring you can confidently handle interviews and navigate the legal complexities. 

Contact Pierce & Shows of Louisiana today to schedule a free review and consultation, and let us guide you through this challenging process. 

Skip to content